Storm & insurance claim guide

Hail Damage Roof Claim Denied? What To Do Next

A denial letter is not always the end of the claim. Some denials are correct — and if your roof is simply old, we will tell you so. But adjusters miss damage, rush through inspections after big storms, and sometimes apply the wrong reason. Here is how to tell the difference and what you can do.

1-800-JOHN-BEAL Free Inspection

Common reasons hail claims get denied

“Wear and tear” or age. The adjuster decided the shingle problems are normal aging, not storm damage. Aging and hail damage look different up close — hail leaves random bruises and fractures, aging is more uniform.

“No hail damage found” or “not enough damage.” Many adjusters count hits inside a sample area on each slope. If they inspected the wrong slope, inspected from a ladder, or missed soft-spot bruises, the count comes up short.

“Cosmetic damage only.” Some policies exclude cosmetic damage, most often on metal roofing and trim. Whether a dent is purely cosmetic, or actually affects how the roof works, is often worth a second look.

“Old storm” or pre-existing damage. The insurer believes the damage happened before your policy started or before the date you reported.

“Below your deductible.” The estimate came in under the deductible, sometimes because damage on the gutters, vents and other slopes was left out.

Late reporting. The claim was filed after the deadline in your policy.

Step 1: Get the denial in writing and read it closely

Ask for the denial letter, the adjuster’s estimate and photos, and any engineer report in writing. The letter should name the specific reason and the policy language it relies on.

Pull out your full policy — not just the declarations page. Look for the wind/hail deductible, whether the roof is covered at replacement cost or actual cash value, any cosmetic damage exclusion or roof payment schedule, and the deadlines for disputing a decision.

Step 2: Get an independent roof inspection

Have a roofer who did not work for the insurer inspect the roof and document it slope by slope: photos of every hit with chalk marks, measurements of the hits, granule loss, fractured shingle mats, and dents on metal vents, flashing and gutters.

Collect proof that hail actually hit your area on the date of loss. Local hail reports, weather service storm data and photos of damage to your gutters, AC unit, siding and cars all help.

Step 3: Ask for a reinspection

If the new evidence shows damage the adjuster missed, request a reinspection in writing, reference your claim number and attach the photo report. Ask that your roofer be allowed to be there. Our guide to requesting a roof reinspection walks through it.

Step 4: If they still say no

Appraisal. Many homeowner policies include an appraisal clause for disagreements over the amount of loss. Each side picks an appraiser, and an umpire settles what they cannot agree on. Check your policy for the exact process.

Your state insurance department. Every state where we work has a consumer complaint process: the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance, Kansas Insurance Department, Illinois Department of Insurance, Indiana Department of Insurance, Ohio Department of Insurance, Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services, Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, Minnesota Department of Commerce, Iowa Insurance Division and Nebraska Department of Insurance.

A public adjuster or attorney. A licensed public adjuster works for you on the claim, usually for a percentage of the settlement. An attorney can review coverage disputes. See our guide to second opinions and third-party help.

When a denial is right

Sometimes the adjuster is correct: the roof is old, the damage is wear, or the hail was too small to hurt the shingles. If that is what we find, we tell you plainly, and we can give you honest options — a repair to buy time, or a fairly priced replacement with financing.

Related storm and claim guides

Storm damage help in your city

John Beal Roofing has local crews inspecting storm-damaged roofs across the Midwest. Choose your area for local storm, neighborhood and roofing information:

Missouri

Kansas

Wichita roofing & storm damage

Illinois

Indiana

Indianapolis roofing & storm damage

Ohio

Michigan

Wisconsin

Frequently asked questions

Can I reopen a denied hail claim?

Often, yes. If you have new evidence, such as an independent inspection showing damage the adjuster missed, you can ask your insurer for a reinspection or reconsideration. Check your policy for deadlines.

Why did my neighbors get new roofs and I was denied?

Roofs of different ages, materials and slopes take hail differently, and different adjusters reach different conclusions. A second inspection will show whether your roof has comparable damage.

Will John Beal Roofing handle my claim for me?

We inspect, document the damage and meet your adjuster on the roof. We are roofers, not public adjusters, so negotiating the claim itself stays between you and your insurer or a licensed public adjuster.

Get a free storm damage inspection

Free inspection with a slope-by-slope photo report. Three generations since 1947. Answered 24/7.

Call 1-800-JOHN-BEAL Get a Free Inspection